I immediately went to my Ludwig 14 x 6.5 Ludalloy Super Sensitive as I've used this drum as a yardstick for years (it's featured elsewhere on the site). The drum runs a Gretsch top die cast hoop and is the best sounding Ludalloy drum I've tried (I've owned a few). We're talking about a drum that is definately no slouch. However... the differences were immediately noticeable, the N&C had a gorgeous and much more varied tone all of its own, along with more cut and projection. To try to put the volume in perspective, the N&C has the about the same kind of power on a normal full stroke as the Ludwig (with die cast top hoop) does on a full stroke rimshot!!!! Despite having a conventional strainer setup it was easily as sensitive as the Super... very impressive! The Super's best strengths are it's almost military precision on ghost notes and versatility. It's perhaps the best all rounder of the three here, the Ludalloy shell has the most neutral tone meaning you could play this behind various types of music and it would sound fine.
Next for comparison was the old 1920's 14 X 6.5 two piece shelled Heavyweight Brass Ludwig which had already seen off a lot of modern snare drums in a recent visit to a Drum Superstore. In all fairness it did a better job at trying to keep up . The N&C once again had a more colourful tone and better cut although the margin was reduced, especially in the projection stakes. On the other hand if you are after an old vintage tone then the heavyweight is the best bet here. As they say, horses for courses! It certainly highlighted just how good the old time brass Ludwig snares are and you can read more about this drum in another section of the site.
All the drums tested sounded great. In a live environment all of these would get the job done with no problems at all. The subtle differences in tone would certainly be more noticeable on a recording. The further you go down the road with "sound quality" the more you come up against the law of diminishing returns: the further you go the more it costs and the less additional effect it has overall. That said, the Noble & Cooley snare drum has amazing tone, power and sensitivity. You can play it loudly or quietly and it's lovely. I have heard of these snares going into orchestral roles and can see why. Equally, it's great for heavy music due to the projection it has. For the sound page the N & C was deliberately run with minimal dampening to exaggerate the tone which is unique so you can hear it better. Despite the VERY low tech recording method (these drums kick alot more live believe me!) differences can be heard and in a studio this would be more so.CLICK HERE for the sound samples from that day.